Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 


Lately, I’ve become more and more frustrated about the obsession with weight in this country. In the supermarket aisle, you see one tabloid proclaiming a certain actress is dieting herself to death while right next to it another tabloid is declaring an actress maybe ten pounds heavier is getting pudgy. Fat jokes are abundant and unchecked in popular movies. (The Wedding Singer, for instance.) Weight Loss commercials air non-stop on TV, often times showing a woman who in her before-picture didn’t have a discernable weight problem and in her after picture looks like a skeleton covered with skin.
  Just as the economic classes of Upper, Middle and Working class have started to disintegrate into Rich and Poor, weight categories have disintegrated into “fat” and “unhealthily skinny.”
  Women and men who have a slight weight problem spend much more time thinking about it then they need to for their health, and people such as myself who actually are significantly overweight are treated like second-class citizens.
  Now, I have some brief pointers I’d like to offer for any the general public who may have been rude to overweight people in the past without realizing it:

1."At least you have such a pretty face,” is not compliment. Neither is “You would be so pretty if you just lost weight.” If you can’t figure out why these are not compliments, say these sentences to yourself in the mirror and see how they make you feel.
2.Fat People are not Deaf. When you make comments about our weight, clothing, prospects for finding a mate, or other assorted characteristics while you’re standing right next to us, we hear you. Quite often we ignore you, but we still hear you.
3.Whether we can hear you or not, fat people are no less entitled to respect than anyone else. It’s rude to (A) walk up to us and just start talking about our weight or (B) walk up to someone else and start talking about our weight.
4.Fat people are not all “jolly.”
5.If it’s 100 degrees out, I’m going to wear a skirt. I don’t care what you have to say about it. So please do me a favor and keep your mouth shut.

  (That last one really just applies to me.)
  In my experience and the experience of many of my friends and family, yo-yo dieters all, people are less likely to be polite to an overweight person. People are less likely to open doors for a fat woman. There is a distinct difference in the way thin people and overweight people are treated. This is unfair, plain and simple.
  Some people say that being overweight is unhealthy and due to overindulgence, and is simply a problem that should be dealt with quickly like a bad haircut; these people might say that overweight people are not a minority who need to stand up for themselves but simply a group of people who eat too much and have to reap the consequences.
  I have two answers to this. One, it’s very difficult to lose weight once you have gained it. It’s hard to lose weight, period, and it’s also very hard for a person who is significantly overweight to go to the gym and be stared at on the treadmill. Two-
  The idea that it’s okay to treat overweight people differently simply because you think it’s their fault they’re fat is stupid. Sorry, I can’t be subtle about this.
  How a person got fat is irrelevant, although many people gain weight due to illness, depression, pregnancy, or changes in their metabolism as they grow older- meaning, of course, that many people who are skinny now will not be in the future. The point is, though, that everyone deserves respect. (Including, yes, skinny people.)
  People are far too wrapped up in weight these days. A naturally skinny woman is automatically suspected of anorexia, a woman who is the recommended weight for her height and body-type is considered fat, and many of us who are actually overweight feel like we have kick me signs on our backs.
  So, everybody, here is my advice: stop sneaking peaks at everyone else’s scale and possibly stop looking at your own. If you are unhealthy do something about it. If you think I’m unhealthy- keep your opinion to yourself unless I either ask you or you are my physician.
  I think if we all follow this advice, we’ll get along great.
©2006-2009 ~fatgirlstock
:iconfatgirlstock:

Author's Comments

I'd appreciate it if you guys would help me out here. This is an editorial or journalism class and this is my very first draft. Usually I'd do 3 or 4 drafts but the darn thing is due tomorrow. I'm not a great first draft writer- I would say I suck, but that's exaggerating a tiny bit. But if you happen to read this, could you tell me what you like and what you don't?

I was going to write about the sucky service I received at Albertson's the other day but the second I started I started grinding my teeth, and it hurt.

P.S. I mention the Wedding Singer in a slightly negative light- which sucks cause I really like that movie. I wanna replace it with a more current movie that had too many fat jokes but I never get to the movies any more. Any ideas?

Comments


love 1 1 joy 2 2 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 1 1 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconlongstock:
It's wonderfully written, but I did notice this:
"I have two answers to this. One, it’s very difficult to lose weight once you have gained it. It’s hard to lose weight, period, and it’s also very hard for a person who is significantly overweight to go to the gym and be stared at on the treadmill. Two-..."
You gave two answers where you'd stated you'd have one. Maybe explain that you're clarifying the first statement.
"we have kick me signs"
Should 'kick me' be in quotes? I'm not actually sure, but I think so. Maybe somebody else knows.
It's a great, thought-provoking essay. :D

--
My photo account ~ ~SidelongGlance
:iconfatgirlstock:
Thank you for reading it! And thanks for the suggestions. I think you're right about both.
:iconlongstock:
No problem - glad to help. :D

--
My photo account ~ ~SidelongGlance
:iconkutekyla:
Very well written. A great read and it reached me on a personal level.

My suggestions for movies would be:
Shallow Hal or Date Movie

Both equally sickening to overweight people. (Date Movie is more recent)

--
scha·den·freu·de
:iconfatgirlstock:
Good, I'm really glad you liked it. That makes me more sure about turning it in. (I trust your taste.)

I changed it to Date Movie. Shallow Hal was pretty bad, but it at least tried in a few places.
:iconseductivebyatch:
I read this and agree with all the above suggestions. I think you did a good job of writting about a personal issue and experiences that many don't even feel they are in the wrong to be doing.

I have also told persons who have made such comments to me whether writen or verbal, didn't your mother every tell you "IF you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all".
I think more people need to remember that bit of advice in many situations.

I have dealt with this for over 30 years and I have a personal motto,
"If you don't like what I say, don't listen to me. If you don't like how I look, don't look at me. I was not put on this earth to please YOU. Unless I CHOOSE TO!"

--
My stock account *seductivebyatchstock
My Storm-Artists.net

"Life has to be a Bitch, if it was a Slut it would be easy"
"I'd rather die while living, then live when I'm dead" Jimmy Buffett
:iconkutekyla:
I admire your willingness and strength to write about this. Also, thank you (for trusting my taste) :D

--
scha·den·freu·de
:iconltrez:
Hey Ronnie;

If you're gonna use fat as least spell it right - PHAT - for you I'm not thinking any other way!
An YO! anybody else got a problem with that tell 'em see me first.

Large Luis
:jarklarge:
>;p.s. damn I knew that Ebonics gotta be good for something, know what I'm saying!
:iconmacabremoe:
i agree on a lot of points you made, and you wrote it all very well. ^__^

though, in a lot of the personal essays i've written about the American obsession with weight, i tend to go on and on about self acceptance. if people shut up about other people and stare long and hard at themselves, they'll see that they really aren't so hot either. somebody out there will think you're hideous and unattractive no matter what you or the people you know think, and what are you gonna do, dwell on it? no. you're gonna get over it and get on with life. because stopping and saying something to somebody or thinking some way about yourself only makes life more complicated. also, people need to stop thinking in terms of what's attractive and what's not. christ, i'd like to think there's more to life than hooking a man. why should being "hot" to the general populous be my only goal in life?

there's also the issue of image distortion. if i stand right in front of someone and say "i'm two hundred pounds", they shake their head in disbelief and tell me i only look about 160. which STILL, according to them assinine BMI charts, is overweight for the average height of a woman. if you ask somebody to draw their own representation of a woman who is average height and two hundred pounds, they'll draw something way off.

there are SO many things i could continue to babble about, but i probably shouldn't... it might make more work for you and i'd hate to start getting preachy and whatnot. ^__^

--
that's Moe's :twocents: ^.^

SEE SISSY’S GALLERY ^.^ [link]

SEE BRIAN'S GALLERY O.o [link]

"and yes, i will always be just a little bit fat." - Bridget Jones
:iconjohnraptor:
Well said and well worth saying. I especially like how you point out the false dichotemy of "fat" vs. "too skinny." If I may offer one suggestions: I feel like it needs a little more in the way of introduction and conclusion. Maybe just a sentence or two would do it. I just think it could use a little more lead-in and wrap-up.

--
I reject your reality and substitute my own.

My website: [link]
My livejournal: [link]
My CafePress store: [link]

Details

July 24, 2006
4.3 KB

Statistics

156
39 [who?]
1,903 (0 today)
39 (0 today)

Site Map